FIFA 23 Everton Ratings: Toffees house one of the WEAKEST squads in the Premier League

FIFA 23 is just around the corner, and it won't be long until we get our first look at some of the brand-new ratings for each team.

Check below to see our predictions for how Everton could look in this year's game.

Top Players

There's no denying that Everton were particularly dreadful last season, only surviving relegation by the skin of their teeth.

With top striker Richarlison leaving and no real quality brought in, it's looking like it will be another tough year for the Toffees.

With that in mind, they'll need some of these stars to perform if they're going to stay up.

Jordan Pickford

A hero for many reasons, Pickford was one of the brighter lights for Everton last season, with a particularly sensational display against Chelsea giving Everton fans hope.

FIFA 23 Pickford Rating
expand image
SAFE HANDS - Jordan Pickford is Everton's top star

Whilst no one wants their goalkeeper to be their best player, we think Pickford will maintain a top rating in FIFA 23.

Dominic Calvert-Lewin

He may look flash on the catwalk, but that does about seem the only place that Dominic Calvert-Lewin isn't injured.

FIFA 23 Calvert-Lewin rating
expand image
OUT OF FORM - Calvert-Lewin will need to be a hero this season

Certain for a downgrade following a poor and inconsistent season, Everton will need this man to start scoring if they're going to survive the drop.

Demarai Gray

Demarai Gray had a standout season for Everton last year, with the winger providing a small glimmer of hope in an otherwise underwhelming year.

FIFA 23 Demarai Gray
expand image
BRIGHT SPARK - Gray is one of Everton's brightest players

Him and fellow winger Anthony Gordon will both receive upgrades this year, but we're not expecting too many other Everton players to share their positive fate.


It's been a quiet transfer window so far for Everton, with things set to heat up before the deadline closes.

A striker is a priority, with little business done so far to bolster the Toffees' attack.

FIFA 23 Dwight McNeil Rating
expand image
MORE TO DO - Everton need to spend wisely before the window shuts

Dwight McNeil has signed from Burnley with Amadou Onana also signing for a large fee.

However, when all is said and done, you can't help but feel like Everton will need a major rebuild moving forward.


Unfortunately, we don't think many Everton players will be receiving upgrades this year.

Anthony Gordon is the only obvious contender for an upgrade, with the young winger proving himself to be a hero last season.

FIFA 23 Anthony Gordon rating
expand image
WONDERKID - Anthony Gordon is a wanted man

Gordon could rise almost 10 overall ratings, with Everton's newest hero more than deserving of a gold card.

Apart from a potential for Gray, we can't see anything but red for this Everton side.


There will be A LOT of downgrades for this Everton team, with Calvert-Lewin, Allan, Mina, Coleman, Rondon and more all set for a drop.

FIFA 23 Allan Ratings
expand image
DOWN WE GO - Plenty of Everton players will be downgraded this year

No players justify an upgrade - other than Gordon and Gray - and whilst some will save face and stay the same, plenty will see their rating plummet.

With all that in mind, we don't think Everton will be anyone's favourite team to use in FIFA 23.

This Article's Topics

Explore new topics and discover content that's right for you!