- Primary Subject: MLB The Show 27
- Key Update: Yordan Alvarez, Junior Caminero, and Cam Schlittler emerge as top cover star candidates following strong 2026 seasons, alongside dark horse picks like Bobby Witt Jr., Juan Soto, and Matt Olson.
- Status: Speculation / Unconfirmed
- Last Verified: October 19, 2026
- Quick Answer: Yordan Alvarez, Junior Caminero, and Cam Schlittler lead predictions to replace Aaron Judge as the MLB The Show 27 cover star.
With the World Series over, the 2026 MLB season is now complete, and the baseball fans' attention is starting to turn towards MLB The Show 27.
One of the things fans are most curious about is who will take over Aaron Judge as the cover star and face of the MLB The Show franchise.
Yordan Alvarez and Bobby Witt Jr. are among the favorites, but there are also some dark horse picks that might surprise you.
MLB The Show 27 Cover Star Predictions
Yordan Alvarez is the main candidate to grace the MLB The Show 27 cover. The Astros designated hitter was the best hitter in all of baseball for most of the 2026 season, with a batting average of .316, 106 RBI's, and 42 home runs.
Alvarez might not have the level of popularity of Aaron Judge or Shohei Ohtani, but he's a de facto superstar coming off a tremendous year.
Because of that, a spot on the cover of MLB The Show 27 would be well-deserved for the Astros' biggest star.
Junior Caminero comes just after Alvarez, as the Tampa Bay Rays superstar third baseman is coming off an elite season, recording 42 home runs and 101 RBIs, which earned him an All-Star selection.
Caminero is one of the most exciting young players in the league, and San Diego Studio likes to feature rising stars in their covers; Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Fernando Tatis Jr. are two great examples of that.
So Caminero possesses phenomenal stats, the star power, and checks all of the boxes in the San Diego Studio cover star checklist.
Cam Schlittler closes out the top three, as the Yankees pitcher scored 239 strikeouts on his way to winning the AL ERA title and earning an AL All-Star selection.
Schlittler plays under the bright lights of New York, which helps him in the popularity department, and his 2026 season numbers cemented him among the elite pitchers in the league.
If San Diego Studio wants to feature an elite pitcher, something that doesn't happen often, on the cover of MLB The Show 27, then Cam Schlittler is the ideal pick.
When it comes to dark horse candidates, Matt Olson, Juan Soto, and Bobby Witt Jr. are names that need to be considered, but for different reasons.
Juan Soto is one of the league's biggest stars, and the Mets superstar had a good season, despite missing 51 games.
Matt Olson is coming off another 40+ home run season and is a popular veteran player, even if his popularity level doesn't reach that of Juan Soto.
Playing for a very popular franchise, the Atlanta Braves, also increases Matt Olson chances of gracing the cover of MLB The Show 27.
Last but not least, we have Bobby Witt Jr., a dynamic superstar who also had a good 2026 season, even if it wansn't it's best career year.
Bobby Witt Jr. earned his third consecutive All-Star Selection and is the face of the Kansas City Royals.
While he isn't as popular as names like Juan Soto or Yordan Alvarez, Bobby Witt Jr. still has a decent chance of featuring on the cover of MLB The Show 27, especially if San Diego Studio opts for a multi-athlete cover.
Stay tuned to RealSport101.com: The Home of Sports Gaming News, Guides, Leaks, and Reviews!