MLB The Show 23: Best catchers in Franchise Mode

It's often a forgotten position, but these are the MLB The Show 23 best catchers. These guys are crucial defensive players and need to deliver at the plate as well.

Having a great catcher can often be the icing on the cake when it comes to building an unstoppable team in MLB The Show 23. They will be taking to the plate as regularly as shortstops and center fielders so you can't ignore this position.

Let's take a look at the best catchers in MLB The Show 23.

Best catchers in MLB The Show 23

You can't just go off OVR for the best catchers this year. It's a solid guide, but doesn't tell the whole story when it comes to a position as complicated as catcher.

These guys need to be agile and quick behind the plate to block wild pitches and have a great arm to throw out runners. They also need to produce at the plate. While often a secondary talent in real life, in MLB The Show 23 you can't compromise offensive output.

JT Realmuto (90 OVR)

Team: Philadephia Phillies

Age: 32

JT Realmuto has been the best catcher in baseball for a while now. The two-time Gold Glove winner mashed 22 homers with a .276/.342/.478 slash line last season for the Phillies as he once again produced with the glove and the bat.#

JT Realmuto player card in MLB The Show 23
expand image

In MLB The Show 23 Realmuto has stellar defensive attributes. He has 97 accuracy and 95 arm strength to throw out runners with ease. He's also got great skills at the plate with 74 contact vs R and 74 contact vs L.

Salvador Perez (83 OVR)

Team: Kansas City Royals

Age: 32

Sal Perez is our next choice. The veteran Royal has claimed five Gold Gloves in his career and mashed a ridiculous 48 home runs in 2021. He fell back to earth a little in 2022 with 23 dingers and a solid .254 average.

In MLB The Show 23 Perez brings awesome power to the plate for a catcher. His 92 power vs L and 82 power vs R make him a threat to go deep in any park while his 80 clutch means he will produce in key moments. He's not brilliant behind the plate anymore but will make up for passed balls with the offensive production.

Wilson Contreras (83 OVR)

Team: St. Louis Cardinals

Age: 30

Wilson Contreras is next on our list. The Cardinals catcher is a three-time All-Star and has hit 20+ homers in three of the last four seasons. He's next been one for average, hittng .243 last year, but his bat is powerful.

Wilson Contreras player card in MLB The Show 23
expand image

In MLB The Show 23 Contreras has 90 power vs L to crank homers. behind the plate he's very solid, with 89 arm strength and 70 blocking to keep the ball in front of him.

Have an opinion on this article? We'd love to hear it!

Alejandro Kirk (86 OVR)

Team: Toronto Blue Jays

Age: 24

If you are looking for a catcher of the future Alejandro Kirk is the one for you. 2022 was his first full year in the Majors and he hit 14 homers with a strong .285 average and 19 doubles.

He's got great plate skills in MLB The Show 23. With 80 contact vs L and 78 contact vs R he can keep rallies going. He's also got an awesome 92 fielding, 91 reactions, and 80 blocking.

Will Smith (88 OVR)

Team: Los Angeles Dodgers

Age: 28

Next up is Will Smith. The Dodgers catcher has hit 49 homers over the last two seasons, and had a strong slash line of .260/.343/.465 last season as he established himself in the Majors.

MLB the Show 23 Will Smith player card
expand image

Smith is a solid all-rounder in MLB The Show 23, without any real standout attributes. He's got 80 power vs R with 78 contact vs L and behind the plate his best attribute is 77 arm strength.

More best catchers in MLB The Show 23

Adley Rutschman
Baltimore Orioles
Travis d'Arnaud
Atlanta Braves
Danny Jansen
Toronto Blue Jays
Tyler Stephenson
Cincinnati Reds
Sean Murphy
Atlanta Braves
Cal Raleigh
Seattle Mariners
William Contreras
Milwaukee Brewers
Kyle Higashioka
New York Yankees
Nick Fortes
Miami Marlins
Eric Haase
Detroit Tigers
This Article's Topics

Explore new topics and discover content that's right for you!

MLB The Show
Have an opinion on this article? We'd love to hear it!